Saturday, January 28, 2012

Part I: Birthright

Birthright has been both a terrific and challenging experience - probably way too much for one blog post.

Big picture highlights:
-  free trip
-  outstanding hearts and minds to share with
-  finding out that I still know how to make friends
-  getting to chill and travel with Marco
-  meeting wonderful and passionate Israeli friends
-  seeing the physical beauty of the landscape of Israel
- learning more about current and historical conflicts that have shaped the region
-  respectful debates
-  fun party opportunities
-  not a religious trip

Big picture lowlights:
-  not getting to learn enough about the Israeli government/the conflict between religious and secular populations
-  the Birthright agenda (i.e. "have Jewish babies")
-  guided processing, rather than having time to reflect alone or  in small groups
-  some questions being ignored or selectively answered
-  implicit messages equating Judaism and/or spirituality with Zionism

I'll throw some pictures up on picasa post-haste - can't wait to talk and write more about my experience in Israel with all of you.

5 comments:

  1. pretty much my feelings about the birthright trip. Hope to hear more about it in person IN CHINA...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hell yeah, lax!

      we had a small crew of people who shared a similar perspective on the whole deal to me, but it was great to debate with people who had more zionist viewpoints, too. overall a lot of great learning and i'm totally infected with the travel bug now! and an actual cold, too :(

      Delete
  2. Can you put a link to your Picasa? I took myself off Google+ and this is the first time I'm majorly regretting it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I had a very similar feeling from my trip too! I guess I'm interested in politics in general but I thought that I'd be able to learn more about the Israeli point of view on current controversial topics.... they definitely steered clear of those!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yeah, they wanted us to feel as "at home" as possible, and the controversy and internal conflict isn't a very sexy picture to paint for impressionable twentysomethings. Still a marvelous trip with amazing new friends! Yay!

    ReplyDelete